Thread history

Fragment of a discussion from Talk:LiteRumble
Viewing a history listing
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Time User Activity Comment
No results

There is something fishy with a chart in the right part close to the end. If you look at above CunobelinDC score distribution you would see that there is no corresponding red points for stronger opponents, while blue and grean are there. This is quite common theme for other bots as well.

Also have a look at this EvBot score distribution you would see the problem with normalizing, i.e. about 1/4 of the space in the right part of the chart has no points. Which is non optimal use of the chart space.

Beaming (talk)16:44, 18 November 2013

Is it still showing the problem? I don't see anything wrong right now. I had some issues with (I suspect) bad bytecode and versioning, but that should be fixed now.

As for the EvBot chart, that is because in meleerumble nobody gets higher than ~75%, so the top 25% is empty. Although I guess I could normalise to the top score, I'd rather have the charts consistent as better bots are released.

Skilgannon (talk)17:55, 18 November 2013

Aha, I see now why melee charts were somewhat off.

But I insist that I do not see red points for X>95% for CunobelinDC. Look at 5 the rightmost green points, I cannot locate red (APS) or blue for the same X values. It might be aliasing problem or may be points are just on top of each other.

Beaming (talk)18:41, 18 November 2013

Green is survival, and so the X value is the average survival score of the enemy bot. The red and blue use enemy APS as the X value, not survival, and since survival scores are higher the green dots go further to the right.

I've actually thought about changing the X axis to just be enemy APS to make it easier to interpret. Or ordering the X-axis by rank instead of using APS values.

Skilgannon (talk)09:22, 19 November 2013

I've changed it so they all use APS on the X axis, so it should be clearer now.

Skilgannon (talk)11:03, 19 November 2013

I like new charts better and they are easier to understand. Thanks.

They are some white space on left and right, but I think it is ok since presentation is clearer now.

There is amasing correlation between APS and Survival in roborumble scores :)

Beaming (talk)14:51, 19 November 2013
 

Would it be a good idea, to make survival difference green on bot comparison charts? This way color scheme matches the main chart.

Beaming (talk)15:26, 19 November 2013
 

Sorry to be such a pain. But I have one more thought. May be APS as X axis is not such a good choice. Since in meleerumble there is white spaces on left and right. No bots have APS above 70% and below 10%.

Would it be better to use rating? Or may be ANPP? Those take full scale.

Beaming (talk)03:00, 20 November 2013