Remove bots with underscores in version numbers?

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Revision as of 27 August 2017 at 18:47.
The highlighted comment was created in this revision.

Remove bots with underscores in version numbers?

It seems that roborumble thinks SimpleBot 0.023h_knn to be a bot named "SimpleBot_0.023h" with version number "knn", and failed to retire it from the rumble.

How can I remove it anyway from the rumble?

    Xor (talk)06:56, 26 August 2017

    Do not worry, it is already gone. It just take a bit of time for rumble to process it.

    By the way, you can add flag for your bot.

      Beaming (talk)07:37, 26 August 2017

      No it is still there. And it is not removed because the literumble says ERROR. name/game does not exist: aaa.SimpleBot_0.023h knn/roborumble

      If you see http://literumble.appspot.com/Rankings?game=roborumble, and search, there will be 3 SimpleBot, as the old ones are failed to remove.

      the problem is not in roborumble@home, as the request body is version=1&game=roborumble&name=aaa.SimpleBot_0.023h_knn&dummy=NA which is raw data.

      But the server handles version numbers with underscores badly, the server thinks it is "aaa.SimpleBot_0.023h knn".

        Xor (talk)07:49, 26 August 2017

        Hmm, yeah, LiteRumble itself seems to see the versions correctly. The rankings, anyway. I'm not sure if it's a client bug encoding the URL or the bot removal endpoint on the server that has a parsing bug (or both, even). In any case, I think we may need Skilgannon to manually retire the old bots, or maybe tell us how to do it.

          Voidious (talk)15:33, 26 August 2017
           
           

          Hey, sorry for the delay. This has been a longstanding problem with the rumble client. In some interfaces it replaces the spaces with underscores, and in others it doesn't and expects the server to do it. In order to be compatible I had to replace the last _ with a space in the server. It can't be the first _, because many bots have _ in their names. However I hadn't considered what would happen if we have _ in the version. Manually removing is a little complicated, I think I'd actually have to patch the code. However that doesn't prevent this from happening again.

          I guess maybe I need some more intelligent logic in splitting the version and the name. Maybe this should be done as a challenge? It is a fairly 'soft' problem, and we have a bunch of input data (the rumble population) that we can verify the algorithm on. Bonus points if it is written in Python.

          So the basic requirements are:

          • Has the same behavior as 'replace last _ with space' for the current rumble population
          • If you add an _suffix in the version number of any of the current bots, correctly detect that it is in the same prefix version, and the suffix you add is part of the version.
            Skilgannon (talk)20:47, 27 August 2017